Next Dallas Cowboys Head Coach: Top Candidates If Cowboys Move On From McCarthy

Fact Checked by Thomas Leary

  • All is not well in Dallas, with the Cowboys sitting at 5-7.
  • Could Jerry Jones move on from Mike McCarthy
  • Candidates could include Bill Belichick, Deion Sanders and Ben Johnson.

Dallas Cowboys fans always expect their team to play for the Super Bowl, and while the ultimate goal has eluded them for nearly 30 years, the team has made the playoffs the past three seasons under coach Mike McCarthy.

However, this season, the Cowboys have taken a step or two back, and if there was Texas sports betting, they'd rarely be a favorite. Thanks to a five-game skid in the middle of the season, Dallas finds itself at 5-7 and in third place in the NFC East.

McCarthy’s team is 1-5 at home this season and has lost those games by an average of 20 points.

Making matters worse, quarterback Dak Prescott is out for the season, leaving the Cowboys in the hands of Cooper Rush for the rest of the way.

With McCarthy’s contract up at the end of this season, it’s fair to ask if he’s on the hot seat, even if owner Jerry Jones publicly backs him. At BetTexas.com, we’ve created exclusive odds on who might replace McCarthy should Jones decide it is time to move on. These odds are for infotainment purposes only, and you will not find these odds at any sportsbook in a neighboring state, like DraftKings or Bet MGM.

Odds For The Next Dallas Cowboys Head Coach

Candidate

Current Job

Odds

Percent Chance

Ben Johnson

Current Lions OC

+450

18.2%

Bill Belichick

Former Patriots Head Coach

+500

16.7%

Mike Vrabel

Former Titans Head Coach

+700

12.5%

Aaron Glenn

Current Lions DC

+700

12.5%

Bobby Slowik

Current Texans OC

+1100

8.3%

Joe Brady

Current Bills OC

+1100

8.3%

Kliff Kingsbury

Current Commanders OC

+1250

7.4%

Deion Sanders

Current Colorado Head Coach

+1500

6.3%

The Field

 

+1000

9.1%

Disclaimer: These odds are for information purposes only and are not available through licensed sportsbooks in surrounding states. Sports betting is not yet legal in Texas, but our site is monitoring what happens in Dallas and will let you know when sportsbooks like DraftKings and BetMGM Texas become available

Johnson, Belichick, Vrabel Could All Be In Play

You can expect Ben Johnson’s name to be bandied about a lot in the offseason. The 11-1 Lions not only have the best record in the NFC, but they have also scored the second-most points, 383, in the entire NFL. Cowboys fans saw that firsthand a month ago when the Lions obliterated McCarthy’s team 47-9 at home.

However, Jones will have options should he decide to hire someone with head coaching experience. The biggest name out there is Bill Belichick (+500), the legendary coach who guided the New England Patriots to six Super Bowl wins over 17 years. If the Cowboys were to land Belichick, it wouldn’t be the first time they made a splashy hire. Back in 2003, the team brought in Bill Parcells, Belichick’s mentor, to coach the team. However, in his four years there, Parcells only took the team to the playoffs twice, and they never got past the Wild Card round.

Should Belichick not be an option, one of his former players could be in line for the job. Mike Vrabel (+700) had success initially in Tennessee, earning coach of the year honors in 2021 after the Titans posted a 12-5 season. Unfortunately, the wheels came off the following season, as the Titans ended the year losing seven straight games and missed the playoffs. He was let go a year later after a 6-11 season.

The splashiest hire, though, is the longest shot on our board. Former Cowboy Deion Sanders (+1500) is racking up wins this season in the college ranks at Colorado, and the Buffaloes will likely boast the Heisman Trophy winner in Travis Hunter in a few weeks.

In November, Sanders’ former Dallas teammate, Michael Irvin, asked him on FS1’s Speak if he would consider becoming the Cowboys coach. Sanders, laughing, told Irvin and the other panelists that he was enjoying himself too much in the college game to consider the Cowboys job.

It wasn’t a definitive no, but it shows why we have Coach Prime so low on our board. For now. 

USA Today photo by David Butler II.

Author

Steve Bittenbender

Steve is an accomplished, award-winning reporter with more than 20 years of experience covering gaming, sports, politics and business. He has written for the Associated Press, Reuters, The Louisville Courier Journal, The Center Square and numerous other publications. Based in Louisville, Ky., Steve has covered the expansion of sports betting in the U.S. and other gaming matters.

Cited by leading media organizations, such as: